3
By Stephen Compall
Jul 30, 2010 09:38 AM EST

Dinner For Schmucks Theatrical Review

Dinner For Schmucks Theatrical Review
Purchase  Blu-ray | Digital HD
Where should we place him on the Michael Scott axis?  It is the first question brought to our minds by the appearance of by now quite typecast Steve Carell (The Office, The 40-Year Old Virgin).  It is easiest to say in this regard, though perhaps a bit unfairly, that Barry (Carell) is a slightly nicer and more creative Michael Scott with special powers appropriate to his personality.

Of course, Barry is fundamentally good-natured, so to side with Tim (Paul Rudd, Clueless, I Love You, Man), as we are expected to, we must accept that he would befriend Barry, though perhaps after a fashion.  But Barry's special ability to arrange extremely embarrassing circumstances to hurt those around him both personally and professionally, the source of most of Dinner For Schmucks's comedy, also serves as the source of all the tension in the film.  Tim frets about the importance of his impending promotion to his relationship with Julie (Jemaine Clement, The Devil Wears Prada, The Rebound), perhaps unnecessarily.  But we, as humans, prefer some semblance of order in our lives; even the most adventurous demand structure, if only in constant danger.  As such, I cannot believe that, given how much damage Barry does to Tim and Julie in only a short time of knowing them, they could stand to be around him for long.  Perhaps Tim really was an idiot, and would have become the architect of his own end, but I must imagine that he would have rather discovered that on his own.

I think that even the filmmakers recognized the ultimate impracticality of friendship with Barry, or were too afraid to pursue the implications of the conceptual core of Barry.  So they gave him further special traits not quite in keeping with the essence of his character.  These serve as the permanent scaffolding of Barry and Tim's relationship, and despite the filmmakers' best efforts, its dissociation with the overall notion of reality in the context of the film is often jarring.  Specifically, these are a uniquely charming artistic gift, and an extreme sense of loyalty to the friends he is hurting, supposing you find loyalty intrinsically valuable.  This is not to say that a "schmuck" is not capable of devotedly producing uniquely charming art, but rather that it strikingly violates the concept of the character.

The latter funny trait, loyalty, causes Barry to occasionally realign his worldview so as to build a friendship with Tim.  But its obvious purpose is to patch holes in that friendship created by Tim's cruelty toward him.  Each time it happens, it seems to turn such a moment of cruelty into a moment of bonding, but we oughtn't forget Tim's underlying impulse, and the ultimate dysfunction in their friendship that it implies.

Supporting characters Kieran (Jemaine Clement, The Flight of the Concords, Despicable Me) and Susana (Kristen Schaal, The Flight of the Conchords, Toy Story 3) provide some pleasant diversions, especially in the former's interactions with Barry.  Unfortunately, setting aside the devaluing of the concept of Barry, the frequent telegraphing of punchlines, in some cases up to a minute in advance, forces us to devalue the key currency of any film such as this: is this funny?

Share this:

Directed By:

MPAA Rating: PG-13
Running Time: 110 minutes
Distributed By: Paramount Pictures

For more information about Dinner For Schmucks visit the FlickDirect Movie Database.

About Stephen Compall

FlickDirect, Stephen  Compall

Ostensibly a programmer from faraway places, Stephen recognizes that making up your mind about movies and television is a simple matter of imposition in the form of review, and he who controls minds controls the world. No word yet on how that second part is progressing. After seeing many films, a few good, for FlickDirect, he returned to faraway places, but still checks in from time to time. Read more reviews and content by .

  • Full Bio
  • Google+
  • Email


comments powered by Disqus

Latest Reviews