Tolkien (2019) Review

By Alyn Darnay   X Formly Known as Twitter
2 Min Read

We’re so used to the glitz and promotion of epic effects-laden productions these days, that it’s easy to miss a small well made and enjoyable film like this. It deserves to be seen, don’t miss it.

Tolkien (2019) Review
Purchase   Physical Media
"In a hole in the ground"…J.R.R. Tolkien wrote, and with those immortal words began the creation of a place known as Middle Earth, a mythological land where Hobbits dwell. "The Hobbit" was published in 1937 and received tremendous critical acclaim. It has been read, taught, admired, loved, and copied ever since.

It spawned what was to be a sequel, but later became the 3rd best selling book ever written, the epic high fantasy novel "The Lord of the Rings." It put such names as Gollum, Aragorn, Gandalf, Frodo Baggins, Sauron, Legolas, and Arwen into the lexicon of our language forever.

Tolkien is arguably the best and most beloved fantasy writer of all time, but who was he, and where did his ideas come from? These are the two burning questions that "Tolkien", the movie attempts to answer. Whether it fully succeeds in accomplishing that task is not as important as the journey the film takes us on. 

Any attempt to explain a famous person's life, talent and values are wroth with the distinct possibilities of missing the central themes that make up the composite of that human being. This attempt, I think, answers those questions, but not in the epic way you'd expect, but rather in quite a small and romantic way. 

Here's The Storyline…

TOLKIEN, the movie, covers the seminal years of the renowned author's life. The story is told mostly in flashback as he searches for a close friend somewhere in the death-strewn trenches of the First World War. It covers the rise and fall and resurrection of the great love of his life, Edith Bratt (LilynCollins/Mortal Instruments), but centers mostly on his school years, where he discovers friendship, courage, and inspiration. 

Tolkien (Nicholas Hoult/ X-Men: Apocalypse), an orphan after his mother's untimely death, was placed in the home of a rich elderly woman by the priest charged to watch over him. At first, he was hesitant to bond with anyone. However, after a series of school events, he finds the fellowship he'd always sought among a small cadre of fellow writers and artists.

As they grow up together, their fellowship strengthens and weathers the trials and tribulations of youthful joy and loss, until the outbreak of World War I, which threatened to tear their fellowship apart. It is the culmination of all these experiences that would later inspire Tolkien to write his famous fantasy novels, and the film makes it easy to see which life events affected his writings most.

The cinematography is beautiful, the acting superb, and the movie captures the period perfectly. Despite some slow pacing, I believe it to be an earnest and well-presented dramatization of the writer's life. I also found it to be an intensely romantic film, enjoying the progression of its story and affectionately touching the audience at many points.

My take… We're so used to the glitz and promotion of epic effects-laden productions these days, that it's easy to miss a small well made and enjoyable film like this. It deserves to be seen, don't miss it.

Grade: B

Directed By:
MPAA Rating: PG-13
Running Time: 112 minutes
Distributed By: Fox Searchlight Pictures

Stream from Amazon Prime

For more information about Tolkien visit the FlickDirect Movie Database. For more reviews by Alyn Darnay please click here.

Tolkien images are courtesy of Fox Searchlight Pictures. All Rights Reserved.

FlickDirect, Alyn   Darnay

Alyn's acclaimed book, entitled "The Script…A Breakthrough Guide to Scriptwriting", has sold over 16,500 copies nationwide, is currently being translated into several languages, and has the honor of being included in The Library of France in Paris. He has written and sold five original film scripts and been published in Newspapers and National Magazines. In addition, he is a frequent guest lecturer at Film Festivals, Colleges, and Universities, holds scriptwriting and acting seminars for professionals several times a year, and has been a staff professor at both the Miami Film School, and the Florida Film Institute.

Read More Tolkien Reviews

Physical Media: Blu-ray Review
Hoult does a fine job portraying the troubled young man who would later become an incredible author. He comes across as intelligent, passionate and compassionate.
Full Review | Grade: C


Today's Digital HD DealsView All

WAS: $14.99
NOW: $4.99
I Know What You Did Last Summer
I Know What You Did Last Summer
WAS: $14.99
NOW: $12.99
Dark Crimes
Dark Crimes
WAS: $12.99
NOW: $7.99

Latest ReviewsView All

Physical Media: Blu-ray Review
Jul 16, 2024 EST
The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare
Physical Media: 4K UHD Review
Jun 25, 2024 EST
A Quiet Place: Day One
Movie / Film Review
Jun 27, 2024 EST