Friends Julie (Jennifer Westfeldt) and Jason (Adam Scott), both single adults have known each other for years. Their circle of friends includes two married couples, Missy (Kristin Wiig) and Ben (John Hamm) and Leslie (Maya Rudolph) and Alex (Chris O'Dowd). Not having luck in the dating field, Leslie has been setting up Julie with a bunch of her lackluster acquaintances. On the other hand, Jason has been bedding some top girlfriend prospects and seems to be settled in his life.
Things start to change when the two married couples start having children as Julie feels her biological clock is running out. On one occasion following a get together with their married friends, Julie offers Jason a proposition of getting her pregnant so she can experience a child with no holds bared including continuing their lives dating other people and having sex. Jason reluctantly agrees opening the proverbial ‘can of worms'.
The film really gets very comical with the married couples interjecting their views about the proposition and butting into Julie and Jason's private lives during the pregnancy. The cast puts on a good show, especially the instigator Leslie aptly played by Rudolph who doesn't seem to have abandoned her demeanor from the recent film Bridesmaids.
Each of the couples has a good chemistry and paired well. Wiig keeps the comedy lively with Missy's defensive attitude for which her husband Ben receives the brunt of her sarcastic comments. While Leslie and Alex are more into seeing that Julie and Jason are on track to keep a reasonable relationship with the child on the way. It gets complicated in a good way however, making the relationships and the outcome reasonably unpredictable.
Writer/Director and actor Jennifer Westfeldt does a pretty good job keeping the story on point and bringing some very good comedy to the screen. Her story does get a little off center at times, but she quickly brings it back in focus on Julie and Jason where the meat of the script belongs. As an actress Westfeldt shines especially with Scott, the two showing great chemistry as an odd couple with a small spark of romance that grows as the play spools out.