The Smurfs (2011) Review

By Nathan M Rose   X Formly Known as Twitter
2 Min Read
The Smurfs (2011) Review
Purchase   Physical Media
Those lovable Smurfs have finally hit the big screen this summer with their first theatrical live-action-film, simply entitled, The Smurfs.

The Smurfs follows the adventures of Papa Smurf and his fellow Smurfs as they are sucked through a magical voxrtex from their world into our modern day society.  However, to add to their troubles, their arch nemesis. Gargamel  (Hank Azaria), along with his sidekick cat, Azriel, are also transported to our world as well.  While trapped in our world, the Smurfs befriend an expecting couple, The Windslows, played by Neil Patrick Harris (How I Met Your Mother) and Jayma Mays (Red Eye), try to help the smurfs get back to their mushroom village.

Helming the daunting task of making the live-action film of the Smurfs was left to Director, Raja Gosnell, known for his family's friend's work on such films as, Home Alone 3, Beverly Hills Chihuahua, and another classic cartoon work --  Scooby-Doo.  However, instead of treating Peyo's Smurf property with respect and creating a family-friendly-film in the likes of Alvin and The Chipmunks or Yogi Bear, Raja Gosnell chooses the go for practical jokes, toilet humor, and the appeal of children.

The Smurfs film has been in a troubled pre-production state since 2003, and it truly shows in the film with it's voice casting, it's live action talent, story depth, and overall translation to a feature length film.

One major issue is the voice actor's cast in the roles of the Smurfs do not appear to correctly reflect their characters' namesake.  A perfect example of this was demonstrated by casting the "happy go-lucky", George Lopez (Beverly Hills Chihuahua) as the voice of Grouchy Smurf, or having Papa Smurf sounding like a bit to young for someone his age.

The comedic talent of Hank Azaria is certainly used well in the film; however, at times it appears to have been "dummied" down to appeal to a kindergarten audience instead of a broad family appeal.  It is also unfortunate that the ever sarcastically funny Neil Patrick Harris was so restrained in his role that he looked like he phoned it in instead of being an intricate part of the cast.

Aside from all of its flaws with it's production, the Smurfs will also not help win back audiences who are starting to see 3D films as a gimmick just to make the studios money.  The post-production 3D on The Smurfs is extremely poor to which you can actually watch the film with without glasses on and still see a very clear picture.

The Smurfs will no doubt connect with its intended audience -- children; however, the Smurfs being an "evergreen" property that appeals to all ages could have  been a very successful movie that appealed to a broad family audience.  Instead family members will be drawing straws this weekend to see who looses to take their children to see this film.

Directed By:
MPAA Rating: PG
Running Time: 102 minutes
Distributed By: Sony Pictures Animation

Stream from Amazon Prime
Watch on Apple TV

For more information about The Smurfs visit the FlickDirect Movie Database. For more reviews by Nathan M Rose please click here.

The Smurfs images are courtesy of Sony Pictures Animation. All Rights Reserved.

FlickDirect, Nathan M Rose

Nathan M Rose is the CEO of FlickDirect Inc. He's is a movie historian, critic, enthusiast, and award-winning podcaster with extensive industry knowledge recognized by news organizations. Nathan believes we might be living in a "Matrix"-like simulation, adding an intriguing perspective to his expertise. Follow Nathan's movie journey on his Letterboxd account.

Read More The Smurfs Reviews

Physical Media: 4K UHD Review
For those, like me, who remember the cartoon, this movie is a pleasant stroll down memory lane.  The Smurfs are well animated with special attention given to details.
Full Review | Grade: B


Today's Digital HD DealsView All

Lights Out
Lights Out
WAS: $14.99
NOW: $12.99
Any Given Sunday
Any Given Sunday
WAS: $12.99
NOW: $7.99
Gone in 60 Seconds
Gone in 60 Seconds
WAS: $17.99
NOW: $4.99

Latest ReviewsView All

Bad Boys: Ride or Die
Movie / Film Review
Jun 04, 2024 EST
The Watchers
Movie / Film Review
Jun 07, 2024 EST
Bob Marley: One Love Steelbook
Physical Media: 4K UHD Review
May 28, 2024 EST